SA Admin

The Right to Repair a Used Car in South Africa

For years, dealers told buyers that servicing anywhere but their own workshop would void the warranty. That practice was unbundled by the Competition Commission's Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines back in 2021 — here's what actually changed, and where a dealer can still legitimately say no.

Updated November 2026 8 min read Applies nationwide

The 30-second version

  • The Competition Commission's Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines (effective 1 July 2021, revised 2024) unbundled in-warranty servicing from dealer networks — independent mechanics can generally do warranty-period work without automatically voiding the warranty.
  • A dealer can still refuse a claim if the actual fault was caused by substandard parts or incompetent work at the independent shop — the guidelines protect your right to choose a workshop, not bad workmanship.
  • These are Commission guidelines describing its regulatory approach under the Competition Act, not a standalone law — they carry real weight but aren't the same thing as a statute.
  • A separate 2026 Commission guideline on "Repair, Service and Maintenance Aftermarkets" explicitly excludes motor vehicles — it has no bearing on your car's warranty.
  • If a dealer tries to deny a claim purely on "you didn't service it with us," get the refusal in writing and escalate — that's the exact practice these guidelines were written to stop.

If you've bought a used car that's still inside its manufacturer warranty or service plan period, you've probably heard some version of the old line: service it anywhere but the dealer, and you're on your own if something breaks. For a long time that was standard practice across the South African dealer network, and plenty of buyers still budget around it, paying dealer labour rates for routine servicing purely to "protect the warranty." That link was formally broken by regulation years ago. Knowing exactly what changed — and what didn't — matters whether you're buying a used car still under plan, or you already own one and a dealer is pushing back on a claim.

What changed, and why

The Competition Commission investigated the automotive aftermarket — servicing, maintenance, repairs and parts — and found that tying in-warranty work exclusively to the selling dealer's own network restricted competition and kept independent workshops out of a large, recurring slice of vehicle-servicing work. Its response was the Guidelines for Competition in the South African Automotive Aftermarket: gazetted as a draft on 14 February 2020, finalised in December 2020 under section 77 of the Competition Act, and effective from 1 July 2021, with a revision in 2024 (the exact detail of that 2024 revision hasn't been independently confirmed for this article — see the disclaimer below).

The core change: manufacturers and dealers can no longer make warranty validity conditional on using only their own dealer network for servicing and maintenance during the warranty or plan period. An independent workshop that does competent work to the manufacturer's specification is, as a general rule, allowed to keep that warranty intact.

Don't confuse this with the 2026 guidelines A newer Competition Commission guideline — covering "Repair, Service and Maintenance Aftermarkets," drafted August 2026 and finalised 6 October 2026 — explicitly excludes motor vehicles from its scope. That one is about other consumer-durable repair markets, not cars. The guidelines that actually govern your vehicle's warranty are the older, car-specific Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines described above, already settled and in force since mid-2021.

What "unbundled" servicing actually means for a buyer

Unbundling means the dealer can no longer bundle "stay under warranty" together with "only ever use us" as a single non-negotiable condition. In practice, for a used-car buyer this means:

When a dealer can — and can't — still refuse your warranty claim

The guidelines don't make every warranty claim automatically valid. A dealer still has a legitimate basis to decline cover in specific situations, and it's worth knowing the difference before you assume bad faith.

Valid vs. invalid reasons to deny a claim

  • Valid: the independent repair caused the fault. If an independent workshop used the wrong grade of oil, incorrect parts, or did the work incompetently, and that specific error caused the failure being claimed on, the dealer can decline that claim on the merits — the guidelines don't shield bad workmanship.
  • Valid: the claimed fault is unrelated to maintenance at all. Normal exclusions (wear items, accident damage, modifications) still apply exactly as they would if the dealer had done every service themselves.
  • Invalid: "you didn't service it with us." A blanket refusal based purely on the servicing having been done by a competent independent workshop, with no link shown between that work and the actual fault, is the exact practice the Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines were written to stop.
  • Invalid: refusing to even assess the claim. A dealer can't skip evaluating whether the independent work met specification and just deny on principle — if they're disputing the work, they need to show how it caused the fault.

What to do if a dealer tries to deny a claim over independent servicing

  1. Get the refusal reason in writing. A verbal "no" over the counter is hard to escalate. Ask the service advisor or dealer principal to state, in an email or letter, exactly why the claim is being refused.
  2. Check which kind of refusal it is. If the stated reason is simply that an independent workshop did the work — rather than a specific defect that workshop's work caused — you're looking at the exact practice the guidelines address.
  3. Pull your service paperwork together. Every invoice, parts receipt and job card from the independent workshop that shows the work was done to specification and on schedule.
  4. Escalate past the service desk. Go to the dealer principal, then the manufacturer's national customer-care or warranty department if the dealer won't move — manufacturers are generally more exposed to reputational and regulatory risk on this than an individual franchise.
  5. Lodge a complaint if it's still unresolved. The Competition Commission and the National Consumer Commission can both take a complaint about a dealer or manufacturer tying warranty cover to using only their own network.

Common mistakes and misconceptions

Frequently asked questions

Does using an independent mechanic automatically void my manufacturer's warranty in South Africa?+
No, not automatically. Since the Competition Commission's Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines took effect on 1 July 2021, a dealer generally cannot void an in-warranty vehicle's warranty purely because servicing or repairs were done by a suitably qualified independent workshop rather than the dealer's own service centre. The guidelines unbundled that link. What still matters is whether the independent workshop used parts and procedures that meet the manufacturer's specification, and whether the work that's actually relevant to a specific fault was done competently — a dealer can still decline a claim tied to damage an independent repair genuinely caused.
What exactly are the Competition Commission's Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines?+
They're the Commission's Guidelines for Competition in the South African Automotive Aftermarket, gazetted as a draft on 14 February 2020, finalised in December 2020 under section 77 of the Competition Act, and effective from 1 July 2021, with a 2024 revision. They set out how the Commission approaches competition in vehicle servicing, maintenance, repairs and parts — in particular, unbundling in-warranty servicing from the dealer network so independent workshops can compete for that work. They are guidelines describing the Commission's regulatory approach, not a standalone statute, though they carry real weight because the Commission can act against conduct that contradicts them.
Is this the same as the 2026 Repair, Service and Maintenance Aftermarket guidelines?+
No — don't confuse the two. The Commission's separate guidelines for Repair, Service and Maintenance Aftermarkets (draft published August 2026, finalised 6 October 2026) explicitly exclude motor vehicles from their scope. The car-specific right-to-repair protection used-car buyers actually rely on is the older, already-settled Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines described above, in force since 1 July 2021.
What should I do if a dealer refuses my warranty claim because I used an independent mechanic?+
Ask the dealer in writing for the specific reason the claim is being refused, and whether they're citing a defect the independent repair caused or simply the fact that the work wasn't done by them. If it's the latter, that's the exact practice the Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines address — point to them directly, keep every invoice and parts receipt from the independent workshop as proof the work met specification, and escalate to the manufacturer's head office and, if needed, the Competition Commission or the National Consumer Commission if the dealer won't budge.

Buying a used car still under warranty or plan?

Knowing your right to repair is only half the picture — the RSA Vehicle Guide inspection bundle covers all 60 checks across exterior, engine bay, interior, underbody, test drive and documents, so you know exactly what you're buying before warranty questions even come up.

Get the Complete Inspection Guide Bundle — R299 →

This guide is general information for South African motorists, not legal advice. The Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines are Competition Commission guidelines describing its regulatory approach under the Competition Act — not binding legislation in the way a statute is — and the exact content of the 2024 revision referenced here has not been independently confirmed. Always verify current requirements with the Competition Commission, the relevant manufacturer, or a qualified attorney before relying on this information in a specific warranty dispute.

Buying a used car soon?

The RSA Vehicle Guide inspection system covers 60 checks across exterior, engine bay, interior, underbody, test drive and documents — each with red flags, SA repair costs and walk-away triggers.

Get the Complete Inspection Guide Bundle — R299 →