The 30-second version
- Insurer-published guides consistently point to small, low-value, low-theft-risk cars — the Suzuki Swift and Suzuki S-Presso among them — as cheap to insure, and to higher-theft, pricier-to-repair models as expensive, regardless of what the car costs to buy.
- Naked Insurance's 2026 guide cites a Suzuki Swift at roughly R397/month and a Toyota Corolla at roughly R690/month as representative examples — treat these as illustrative, not a quote you'd actually get.
- Four things drive the gap: engine size and power, parts availability and repair cost, how often the model is stolen or hijacked, and how the car is used.
- The VW Polo is a useful contrast case — TopAuto notes it's comparatively expensive to insure despite being one of SA's cheapest cars to buy, largely because it's also one of SA's most-stolen models.
- These figures come from insurer marketing material, not an independent industry dataset — use them to understand the pattern, then get your own quote on the specific car, year and trim you're considering.
Most buyers price a used car by its sticker price and running costs — fuel, service intervals, tyres — and treat insurance as an afterthought you'll sort out once you've decided. That's backwards for a surprising number of popular models in South Africa, where a car that's cheap to buy can turn out to be one of the more expensive ones to insure every month. A handful of insurer-published guides — Naked Insurance, Pineapple, and vehicle-industry site TopAuto — consistently name the same kind of car as cheap to cover, and it's worth understanding why before you shortlist anything. For the full breakdown of every factor that moves your personal premium up or down, our car insurance premium factors guide covers that in general terms; this guide is about what that looks like when you put specific models next to each other.
What actually makes a car cheap or expensive to insure
Insurers don't price a car on its purchase price alone. Four things do most of the work, and they interact with each other rather than acting independently:
- Engine size and power. A smaller, less powerful engine is statistically involved in fewer and less severe accidents, and insurers price accordingly — a 1.2-litre runabout costs less to cover than a larger-engined car of similar value.
- Parts availability and repair cost. A model with cheap, widely stocked parts and a simple mechanical layout is faster and cheaper to fix after a claim, which keeps the premium down. A car with scarce, imported, or expensive parts pushes it up.
- Theft and hijacking risk. Insurers price by how often a specific model is actually stolen, not by how much it's worth. A commonly targeted car carries a theft-risk loading regardless of how affordable it was to buy.
- How the car is used, and by whom. The same vehicle costs more to insure for a young or inexperienced driver, or for business use, than for an older driver doing a straightforward daily commute — a factor that sits on top of whatever the vehicle itself contributes.
Cars insurer guides point to as cheap to insure
Naked Insurance's 2026 guide to cheap-to-insure cars uses the Suzuki Swift and Toyota Corolla as contrasting examples of what a small, low-risk hatchback costs next to a larger, pricier sedan. Pineapple's own "cheapest cars to insure" list separately includes the Suzuki S-Presso among its examples — reinforcing the same pattern from a different insurer.
| Model | What's cited | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Suzuki Swift | ≈R397/month illustrative premium | Naked Insurance, 2026 guide |
| Toyota Corolla | ≈R690/month illustrative premium (contrast example) | Naked Insurance, 2026 guide |
| Suzuki S-Presso | Listed among cheapest-to-insure models (no figure published) | Pineapple |
The VW Polo: the useful contrast case
The VW Polo is one of South Africa's most affordable cars to buy new or used, and it's also South Africa's most common car on the road. TopAuto notes that despite this affordability, the Polo is comparatively expensive to insure — and the reason tracks directly back to the four factors above rather than anything about the car's purchase price. TopAuto also flags the Polo as one of South Africa's most-stolen models, which is the main driver: a car that gets stolen or hijacked often carries a theft-risk loading that a cheap sticker price can't offset.
If you're specifically looking at a used Polo, our guide to buying a used VW Polo covers its theft ranking in more detail alongside the mechanical checks worth doing before you buy — the two considerations (theft risk and insurance cost, mechanical condition) are separate but both worth weighing on this specific model.
The RSA Vehicle Guide inspection system covers 60 checks across exterior, engine bay, interior, underbody, test drive and documents — each with red flags, SA repair costs and walk-away triggers.
Get the Complete Inspection Guide Bundle — R299 →How to use this when you're actually shopping
- Shortlist on total cost, not sticker price. Add an actual insurance quote to any used car you're seriously considering before comparing it against alternatives — a cheaper car with a high premium can cost more monthly than a pricier one that's cheap to cover.
- Check the specific model's theft ranking. Our South Africa vehicle crime report has the national breakdown of which models are most targeted — a car on that list will usually carry a theft-risk loading no matter how small its engine is.
- Get quotes on the exact year and trim. Engine size, turbo variants and even trim level change the premium on what's nominally "the same" model — don't assume a 1.0-litre base model and a 1.4-litre turbo variant of the same badge insure the same.
- Compare more than one insurer. Naked, Pineapple and the traditional insurers price risk differently — a model that's expensive at one insurer isn't necessarily expensive everywhere. See our premium factors guide for how to shop quotes properly.
Common mistakes
- Assuming a cheap car to buy is automatically cheap to insure — purchase price and insurance cost aren't the same thing, as the VW Polo shows.
- Treating one insurer's published example (like the R397 Swift or R690 Corolla figures above) as the actual premium you'd get, rather than an indicative illustration.
- Shopping on engine size alone and ignoring theft risk, which can outweigh a small engine's saving on a frequently targeted model.
- Not checking a specific model's theft ranking before assuming it's cheap to insure just because it's small or common on SA roads.
Frequently asked questions
Buying any used car? Check the whole thing, not just the premium.
Our Complete Inspection Guide Bundle covers all 60 checks across exterior, engine bay, interior, underbody, test drive and documents — so insurance cost isn't the only thing you've weighed up properly.
Get the Complete Inspection Guide Bundle — R299 →This guide is general information for South African motorists, not financial or insurance advice. The model examples and figures cited come from insurer-published marketing guides (Naked Insurance, Pineapple) and industry reporting (TopAuto), not an independent industry dataset, and actual premiums vary by insurer, driver, address, claims history and policy terms. Always get your own quote on the specific car, year and trim before deciding, and confirm current figures directly with your insurer.
The RSA Vehicle Guide inspection system covers all 60 checks — exterior, engine bay, interior, underbody, test drive and documents — not just the running costs.
Get the Complete Inspection Guide Bundle — R299 →